Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban: Book vs. Movie

I listened to the first half of Prisoner of Azkaban on audio that I had checked out through Overdrive. Unfortunately, I wasn’t able to finish listening to it before it expired. Hence why it took me three months to have the chance to finish it by reading my own copy! I had forgotten how much I absolutely love the third book in this beloved series!! SO MUCH LOVE! So I’m very pleased to bring you the third edition of Harry Potter movie comparison post!

WARNING: BOOK/MOVIE SPOILERS AHEAD!

giphy

Movie: Harry meets and rides Buckbeak for the first time during his very first class of Care of Magical Creatures with Hagrid. Harry is the only one who really interacts with a hippogriff as Buckbeak is the only one present.

VS

Book: Hagrid has multiple hippogriff grazing and multiple students get to interact with them.

sirius_black_wanted_gif_by_nightgrowler-d3443e2Movie: Mr. Weasley takes Harry aside in the Leaky Cauldron to tell him that Sirius Black is coming after him.

VS

Book: Harry overhears a conversation between Mr. and Mrs. Weasley at the Leaky Cauldron about Black being after Harry. Mr Weasley never approaches Harry personally. 

 

tumblr_n577832os31ttwjl4o1_500

Movie: Harry steps up to bogart in Professor Lupin’s class and it turns into a dementor in which Lupin jumps in front of Harry to block. 

VS

Book:Harry never gets a chance to approach the bogart, Lupin stops the class right before Harry can step up to it.

 

sir_cadogan

Movie: Harry, Ron, and Hermione find their own to their first class of Divinations.

VS

Book: A knight Sir Cadogan who is quite buffoon leads them to their class. He is only briefly shown once in the movies and is noticeable only to those who have read the book. He replaces the Fat Lady as the password keeper for Gryffindor after she gets attacked by Sirius.

 

ighajue

Movie: Harry receives the Firebolt from Sirius at the very last scene that arrives with a hippogriff feather.

VS

Book: Harry mysteriously receives a Firebolt as a Christmas present. Nobody can figure out who its from. Hermione suspects its from Sirius whom she believes to be a criminal still at the time. She turns it in to Professor McGonagall who proceeds to have it thoroughly checked for jinxes before returning it back to Harry to use to win the Quidditch Cup, which they do in fact win.

 

200_s

Movie: Harry uses the memory of his parents “just talking” to defeat the dementor bogart when he is training with Lupin. 

VS

Book: Harry meets with Lupin multiple times in order to finally achieve a patronus. The memory he uses to do so is of him being told he is a wizard and that he will be leaving the Dursleys. 

azkaban-deleted009

Movie: Sirius attacks the fat lady and is not seen in human form again on the grounds.

VS

Book: Ron gets attacked in the middle of the night in the boys dormitory. His bed curtains are slashed and McGonagall comes out in her dressing gown to see whats going on. There is actually a deleted freeze frame (seen above) that I think is from this scene but we never actually see it in the movie.

tumblr_ofi04wlaje1uhyxn7o1_500

Movie: Harry sneaks out to Hogsmeade under the invisibility  cloak, and throws snowballs at Malfoy and depants Crabbe and gets away with it.

VS

Book: Harry throws mud at Malfoy but his cloak slips in the process and Malfoy sees his head. He then runs off and tells Snape who confiscates the Marauders Map from him. The map proceeds to insult him in more than one way. Snape then summons Lupin to read the map who takes it from there. 

harry_and_hermione_see_remus_lupin

Movie: The whomping willow is on Hogwarts grounds and it just so happens to be located on top of the secret entrance to the shrieking shack.

VS

Book:Lupin reveals to Harry, Ron, and Hermione whilst they’re all in the shrieking shack that the unique tree was planted specifically for Lupin to use as a form of protection from others when he transformed into a werewolf. 

werewolf_attack

Movie: Hermione howls to distract Lupin from attacking them causing him to run after her and Harry. Lupin as a werewolf then comes after them and almost kills them when Buckbeak fends him off. 

VS

Book: No suspenseful werewolf forrest scene takes place and the book is no less exciting for it! 

cs0jadqxaaavz1_

Movie: As stated previously–at the end of the film, Sirius flys off on Buckbeak after having a heartfelt goodbye with Harry and Hermione. That is the last we see or hear from him until the next film.

VS

Book: Sirius sends a letter to Harry with a tiny cute owl while Harry is on the Hogwarts Express heading back to the Dursleys for the Summer. This is the point in time when he reveals to Harry that it was him that sent him the Firebolt at Christmas. He also tells Ron to keep the owl who had sent the letter so that he would have a new pet to replace Scabbers. 

 

 

Advertisements

Pottermore Presents Ebooks Review

Due to each story corresponding with one another, and the fact that they are so short, I decided it would be best to review all three as one.

31538635

Goodreads Summary:

‘Minerva was the Roman goddess of warriors and wisdom. William McGonagall is celebrated as the worst poet in British history. There was something irresistible to me about his name, and the idea that such a brilliant woman might be a distant relative of the buffoonish McGonagall.’ – J.K. Rowling
Pottermore Presents is a collection of J.K. Rowling’s writing: short reads originally featured on pottermore.com with some exclusive new additions. These eBooks, with writing curated by Pottermore, will take you beyond the Harry Potter stories as J.K. Rowling reveals her inspiration, intricate details of characters’ lives and surprises from the wizarding world.


These stories of heroism, hardship and dangerous hobbies profile two of the Harry Potter stories’ most courageous and iconic characters: Minerva McGonagall and Remus Lupin. J.K. Rowling also gives us a peek behind the closed curtains of Sybill Trelawney’s life, and you’ll encounter the reckless, magical-beast-loving Silvanus Kettleburn along the way. 

31538614

Goodreads Summary:

No Muggle Prime Minister has ever set foot in the Ministry of Magic, for reasons most succinctly summed up by ex-Minister Dugald McPhail (term of office 1858-1865): “their puir wee braines couldnae cope wi’ it.”’ – J.K. Rowling
Pottermore Presents is a collection of J.K. Rowling’s writing: short reads originally featured on pottermore.com with some exclusive new additions. These eBooks, with writing curated by Pottermore, will take you beyond the Harry Potter stories as J.K. Rowling reveals her inspiration, intricate details of characters’ lives and surprises from the wizarding world.


These stories of power, politics and pesky poltergeists give you a glimpse into the darker side of the wizarding world, revealing the ruthless roots of Professor Umbridge, the lowdown on the Ministers for Magic and the history of the wizarding prison Azkaban. You will also delve deeper into Horace Slughorn’s early years as Potions master at Hogwarts – and his acquaintance with one Tom Marvolo Riddle. 

31538647

Goodreads Summary:

‘The Ministry of Magic felt strongly, however, that to construct an additional wizarding station in the middle of London would stretch even the Muggles’ notorious determination not to notice magic when it was exploding in front of their faces.’ – J.K. Rowling
Pottermore Presents is a collection of J.K. Rowling’s writing: short reads originally featured on pottermore.com. These eBooks, with writing curated by Pottermore, will take you beyond the Harry Potter stories as J.K. Rowling reveals her inspiration, intricate details of characters’ lives and surprises from the wizarding world.

Hogwarts An Incomplete and Unreliable Guide takes you on a journey to Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. You’ll venture into the Hogwarts grounds, become better acquainted with its more permanent residents, learn more about lessons and discover secrets of the castle . . . all at the turn of a page.

My Review

Ok so it’s kind of hard to make this an actual review seeing as these books were more of Harry Potter encyclopedias. So there is no real story to review upon. All I can tell you is how they made me feel. Any die hard Potter fan is gonna absolutely adore learning everything there is to know about the Wizarding World! J.K. Rowling inspired all the feels , and her chapter on Remus Lupin had me tearing up all over again. I truly felt like I was being educated on a topic that I sincerely cared about (unlike most my college courses).

The most unique part about the way these books are written is that after each section there is a section titled: “J.K. Rowling’s Thoughts.” You basically get a glimpse inside of her head as she was brainstorming/writing the Harry Potter books. You discover where her inspiration came from and how she thought up the names of characters. She even talks about ideas that she decided not to go with. If anything, reading these books increased my appreciation of her as an author even more! She did so much research, and put so so much thought into constructing the Harry Potter books; it’s absolutely amazing!! Even minor characters (ones I had completely forgotten existed until reading these) were given extensive backgrounds.

Though Rowling does touch on a lot of details I had been wondering about, I can’t help but feel that she could still tell us so much more, and give us spin off books on characters (wishful thinking I know). My inner fangirl would love to see a series written on the Marauders! Oh well, I most definitely enjoyed reading these lovely little ebooks, it made my heart happy and made me what to reread all the books now that I have a greater understanding.

I most definitely recommend any Harry Potter fan read these three books! Buy book the series on Amazon here!